Our promise
The name is the standard
Every car on our lot is hand-picked, inspected, and reconditioned by our own shop before it's offered for sale. We post a free Carfax on every vehicle so you can see exactly what you're buying — no guessing, no games.
Financing? We work with a network of lenders to find options for every credit situation (subject to lender approval), and our in-house DMV means your paperwork gets handled right here. No runaround, no pressure — just a fair deal, square.
Browse Our Inventory
Why buy from us
Five reasons drivers choose Fair & Square
Transparent pricing
Every charge is itemized up front. Beyond the vehicle price you'll pay NY sales tax, title, registration/DMV fees, state inspection, and our posted $175 documentation fee — no hidden back-office markups at signing.
Free Carfax on every car
Full vehicle history on every listing, free. We'd rather you know everything up front.
Financing for all credit
Good, bad, or no credit — our lender network shops for an approval that fits your budget. Subject to lender approval; not all applicants qualify.
In-house DMV
Title, registration and plates handled on-site, so you can just drive off.
BBB Accredited
An accredited Long Island business with a 4.9-star Google rating from 361 real neighbors.
Meet the team
Real people, not a call center
The folks you'll actually deal with when you visit the lot.
-
Aydin
Salesperson
Believes car buying shouldn't feel like a fight. He's on the lot most days, ready to help you find the right one — no pressure.
-
Andrew
Business Manager
Walks you through the numbers, financing, and paperwork — straight answers, no pressure, no surprises.
-
Our Service Team
Recon & Repair
Inspects and reconditions every vehicle before it hits the lot — and is here for you after the sale.
Stop by and see for yourself.
We're at 46 Carleton Ave in Islip Terrace, open 7 days a week. Come browse — no pressure, promise.
Areas we serve
Used cars for Islip Terrace & all of Long Island
Fair & Square Automotive Group sits at 46 Carleton Ave in Islip Terrace, NY 11752 — just off Sunrise Highway in the heart of Suffolk County. We're an easy drive for used-car shoppers across Long Island's South Shore and central towns, and for buyers who can't make it in person we arrange nationwide delivery right to your door.
Whether you're searching for a dependable used SUV, sedan, truck, or family car, we keep a hand-picked, reconditioned inventory with a free Carfax on every vehicle and financing options for every credit situation (subject to lender approval). Come see why neighbors from across Long Island keep choosing us.
Areas we proudly serve
- Islip Terrace
- East Islip
- Islip
- West Islip
- Bay Shore
- Brentwood
- Central Islip
- Sayville
- Bayport
- Oakdale
- Great River
- Holbrook
- Ronkonkoma
- Patchogue
- Hauppauge
- Deer Park
- North Babylon
- Bohemia
- Holtsville
- Suffolk County
What Long Island drivers come to us for
Quality used cars near you
A rotating selection of inspected, reconditioned SUVs, sedans, and trucks at fair, upfront prices. Browse our inventory →
Financing for every credit situation
Good credit, bad credit, or no credit — we shop our lender network for an approval that fits your budget (subject to lender approval). Get pre-qualified →
In-house NY DMV & registration
Title, registration, and plates are handled right here, so you drive off street-legal without the wait. DMV & registration →
Sell or trade your car
Get a fair, no-obligation offer on your current vehicle — you don't have to buy from us to sell to us. Get your offer →
Visit our Islip Terrace dealership
Stop by 46 Carleton Ave, Islip Terrace, NY 11752 — open 7 days a week. Se habla español. Call or text (631) 650-1930, or get directions and hours.