How it works
Coverage handled, not homework
Tell us about the car
Send the short form with the vehicle you're buying and whether you carry insurance now. No policy details needed to start.
We loop in a local agent
We hand you off to one of our independent agency partners — they shop multiple carriers to find you the right coverage at a fair rate.
Drive off insured
The agency issues your ID cards and electronically files proof of coverage with NY DMV, so we can register, plate, and send you home the same day.
In a hurry? Call (631) 650-1930 and we'll connect you with an agent who can quote on the spot.
Get an insurance quote
Sends straight to our team — we'll connect you with a licensed agent, usually within the hour during business hours.
Your information goes only to our team and the agency we connect you with. We never sell your data.
Our partners
Trusted local agencies, major carriers
We work with independent brokers who shop the big names so you don't have to.
Lighthouse Insurance
A local independent brokerage that compares coverage across multiple carriers to fit your budget and your car.
First Choice
Long Island agents who handle auto coverage start to finish — quote, bind, and file proof with the DMV.
Our broker partners write policies with major national carriers, so you get recognized coverage backed by people you can reach in person.
Important disclosure
Insurance is provided through independent, licensed insurance agencies. Fair & Square Automotive Group is not an insurance provider and does not sell, issue, or bind insurance policies. We simply connect buyers with trusted local agents as a convenience. All coverage, rates, terms, and approvals are determined solely by the licensed agency and its carriers. Nothing on this page is an offer of insurance or a guarantee of coverage.
Buying a car this week?
Find your vehicle first, then we'll line up coverage so you can drive it home the same day.